Why does range(start, end) not include end?

Posted on

Solving problem is about exposing yourself to as many situations as possible like Why does range(start, end) not include end? and practice these strategies over and over. With time, it becomes second nature and a natural way you approach any problems in general. Big or small, always start with a plan, use other strategies mentioned here till you are confident and ready to code the solution.
In this post, my aim is to share an overview the topic about Why does range(start, end) not include end?, which can be followed any time. Take easy to follow this discuss.

Why does range(start, end) not include end?
>>> range(1,11)

gives you

[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10]

Why not 1-11?

Did they just decide to do it like that at random or does it have some value I am not seeing?

Answer #1:

Because it’s more common to call range(0, 10) which returns [0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9] which contains 10 elements which equals len(range(0, 10)). Remember that programmers prefer 0-based indexing.

Also, consider the following common code snippet:

for i in range(len(li)):
    pass

Could you see that if range() went up to exactly len(li) that this would be problematic? The programmer would need to explicitly subtract 1. This also follows the common trend of programmers preferring for(int i = 0; i < 10; i++) over for(int i = 0; i <= 9; i++).

If you are calling range with a start of 1 frequently, you might want to define your own function:

>>> def range1(start, end):
...     return range(start, end+1)
...
>>> range1(1, 10)
[1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10]
Answered By: moinudin

Answer #2:

Although there are some useful algorithmic explanations here, I think it may help to add some simple ‘real life’ reasoning as to why it works this way, which I have found useful when introducing the subject to young newcomers:

With something like ‘range(1,10)’ confusion can arise from thinking that pair of parameters represents the “start and end”.

It is actually start and “stop”.

Now, if it were the “end” value then, yes, you might expect that number would be included as the final entry in the sequence. But it is not the “end”.

Others mistakenly call that parameter “count” because if you only ever use ‘range(n)’ then it does, of course, iterate ‘n’ times. This logic breaks down when you add the start parameter.

So the key point is to remember its name: “stop“.
That means it is the point at which, when reached, iteration will stop immediately. Not after that point.

So, while “start” does indeed represent the first value to be included, on reaching the “stop” value it ‘breaks’ rather than continuing to process ‘that one as well’ before stopping.

One analogy that I have used in explaining this to kids is that, ironically, it is better behaved than kids! It doesn’t stop after it supposed to – it stops immediately without finishing what it was doing. (They get this 😉 )

Another analogy – when you drive a car you don’t pass a stop/yield/’give way’ sign and end up with it sitting somewhere next to, or behind, your car. Technically you still haven’t reached it when you do stop. It is not included in the ‘things you passed on your journey’.

I hope some of that helps in explaining to Pythonitos/Pythonitas!

Answered By: dingles

Answer #3:

Exclusive ranges do have some benefits:

For one thing each item in range(0,n) is a valid index for lists of length n.

Also range(0,n) has a length of n, not n+1 which an inclusive range would.

Answered By: sepp2k

Answer #4:

It works well in combination with zero-based indexing and len(). For example, if you have 10 items in a list x, they are numbered 0-9. range(len(x)) gives you 0-9.

Of course, people will tell you it’s more Pythonic to do for item in x or for index, item in enumerate(x) rather than for i in range(len(x)).

Slicing works that way too: foo[1:4] is items 1-3 of foo (keeping in mind that item 1 is actually the second item due to the zero-based indexing). For consistency, they should both work the same way.

I think of it as: “the first number you want, followed by the first number you don’t want.” If you want 1-10, the first number you don’t want is 11, so it’s range(1, 11).

If it becomes cumbersome in a particular application, it’s easy enough to write a little helper function that adds 1 to the ending index and calls range().

Answered By: kindall

Answer #5:

It’s also useful for splitting ranges; range(a,b) can be split into range(a, x) and range(x, b), whereas with inclusive range you would write either x-1 or x+1. While you rarely need to split ranges, you do tend to split lists quite often, which is one of the reasons slicing a list l[a:b] includes the a-th element but not the b-th. Then range having the same property makes it nicely consistent.

Answered By: xuanji

Answer #6:

The length of the range is the top value minus the bottom value.

It’s very similar to something like:

for (var i = 1; i < 11; i++) {
    //i goes from 1 to 10 in here
}

in a C-style language.

Also like Ruby’s range:

1...11 #this is a range from 1 to 10

However, Ruby recognises that many times you’ll want to include the terminal value and offers the alternative syntax:

1..10 #this is also a range from 1 to 10
Answered By: Skilldrick

Answer #7:

Consider the code

for i in range(10):
    print "You'll see this 10 times", i

The idea is that you get a list of length y-x, which you can (as you see above) iterate over.

Read up on the python docs for range – they consider for-loop iteration the primary usecase.

Answered By: Robert

Answer #8:

Basically in python range(n) iterates n times, which is of exclusive nature that is why it does not give last value when it is being printed, we can create a function which gives
inclusive value it means it will also print last value mentioned in range.

def main():
    for i in inclusive_range(25):
        print(i, sep=" ")
def inclusive_range(*args):
    numargs = len(args)
    if numargs == 0:
        raise TypeError("you need to write at least a value")
    elif numargs == 1:
        stop = args[0]
        start = 0
        step = 1
    elif numargs == 2:
        (start, stop) = args
        step = 1
    elif numargs == 3:
        (start, stop, step) = args
    else:
        raise TypeError("Inclusive range was expected at most 3 arguments,got {}".format(numargs))
    i = start
    while i <= stop:
        yield i
        i += step
if __name__ == "__main__":
    main()
Answered By: Ashish Dixit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.