Subprocess.Call: String Vs List – Best Practice Comparison

Posted on
Subprocess.Call: String Vs List - Best Practice Comparison

Python is a powerful and versatile programming language that provides developers with a plethora of tools to accomplish their tasks. One such tool is the subprocess module, which enables developers to execute external commands and interact with their output programmatically. One crucial aspect when using subprocess is the choice between passing your command as a string or as a list of arguments. This decision can impact the outcome of your code, making it essential to understand when to use one approach over the other.

If you’re new to Python programming, the difference between passing your command as a string or as a list might seem subtle. However, the distinction is significant, and the wrong choice can lead to unexpected behaviors or even security vulnerabilities. To help you make an informed decision, this article explores the best practices for using with strings and lists. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of these two approaches and the rationale behind them, empowering you to write better and more secure Python code.

Whether you’re working on a personal project or part of a large development team, mastering is crucial for system automation and process management. Therefore, any serious Python developer must understand the differences between using a command as a string or list in This article breaks it down for you, so you don’t have to sift through lengthy documentation or confusing examples. Follow the tips and tricks presented here to ensure that you use effectively and efficiently.

Are you tired of guessing whether to use a string or a list when executing external commands from Python? Look no further! In this article, we dig deep into and explain the best practices for using strings and lists as commands. Say goodbye to confusion and hello to confidence, as you learn to master like never before. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced Pythonista, this article will enrich your knowledge and make your task of automating system processes smoother and safer.

Subprocess.Call Using String Vs Using List
“Subprocess.Call Using String Vs Using List” ~ bbaz

The Power of Subprocess.Call

When it comes to running command-line programs from within Python code, the go-to solution is often the function. While this function is incredibly versatile and useful, there are some best practices to keep in mind when using it, and one of the most crucial considerations is whether to use a string or a list as the first argument of the function.

The Basics of Subprocess.Call

Before we dive into the differences between using a string and list, let’s take a moment to review the basics of the function. At its core, this function allows Python code to run external programs and receive output from them. Here’s an example of it in action:

“`import[‘echo’, ‘Hello, world!’])“`

This code will run the `echo` program (which simply prints out its arguments) and pass it the argument Hello, world!. The end result will be that Hello, world! is printed to the terminal.

Using a String as the First Argument

The simplest way to use is to pass it a single string that represents the entire command to be run. For example:

“`import‘echo Hello, world!’, shell=True)“`

In this case, the entire command (including quotes) is contained within the single string. This can be more convenient in some cases because it avoids the need to split up the command into individual elements of a list. However, there are some downsides to using a string in this way, which we’ll explore next.

Disadvantages of Using a String

There are a few reasons why it’s generally not recommended to use a string as the first argument of First and foremost, it can be more difficult to read and understand what’s happening in the command. For example, consider this string:

“`command = ‘mv /path/to/file /new/path’“`

It’s easy to see that this command is moving a file from one location to another, but it’s not immediately clear what the separate components of the command are. It might be safer and more intuitive to split up the command into a list like this:

“`command = [‘mv’, ‘/path/to/file’, ‘/new/path’]“`

This makes it more obvious what each of the arguments to the command is.

Another potential disadvantage of using a string is that it can be more difficult to handle special characters or escape sequences. In some cases, the shell=True argument can be used to tell to use the system shell to execute the command, which can handle these special characters more effectively. However, using the shell can also introduce security risks, so it’s generally better to avoid it if possible.

Advantages of Using a List

Overall, it’s generally recommended to use a list as the first argument of whenever possible. One advantage of using a list is that it’s much easier to handle elements that contain spaces or other special characters. For example:

“`import[‘cp’, ‘/path/with space/file’, ‘/new/path’])“`

In this case, the source file path contains a space, but we don’t need to worry about escaping it because it’s contained within its own list element.

Another advantage of using a list is that it can be easier to construct complex commands using Python code. For example:

“`import subprocessfilename = ‘my_file.txt’destination = ‘/new/path’command = [‘tar’, ‘-czvf’, ‘{}.tar.gz’.format(filename), filename]command += [‘&&’, ‘mv’, ‘{}.tar.gz’.format(filename), destination]“`

In this code, we’re using the list to build up a command that first creates a .tar.gz archive of a file, and then moves that archive to a new location. This would be more difficult to do with a string.

Comparison Table

Argument Type Advantages Disadvantages
String – Simpler to write in some cases
– Can handle special characters with shell=True argument
– Harder to read and understand
– Potential security risks with shell=True
List – Easier to read and understand
– Can handle special characters without shell=True
– Can be used to construct complex commands
– Slightly more verbose in some cases


Overall, the choice between using a string or a list as the first argument of should come down to readability and ease of use. While strings can be simpler in some cases, they can also be harder to read and open up potential security concerns. Lists offer more flexibility and power, making them the preferred option for most situations.

Thank you for reading our comparison on Subprocess.Call using String Vs List. We hope that this article has provided you with greater insight into the differences between these two methods and how they can impact your coding practices.

While both methods are valid options, we highly recommend using the List approach as it offers greater flexibility and security. The ability to pass arguments as separate items in a list allows for more precise control over what is being executed and reduces the risk of unintended actions.

Additionally, by using lists, you can easily incorporate user input and other external variables into your code without needing to worry about properly formatting strings. This can save time and reduce errors in the long run.

Overall, whether you choose to use strings or lists when working with Subprocess.Call will ultimately depend on your specific needs and preferences. We encourage you to experiment with both options and determine which approach works best for your particular project.

People also ask about Subprocess.Call: String Vs List – Best Practice Comparison:

  1. What is Subprocess.Call?
  2. Subprocess.Call is a method in Python’s subprocess module that allows you to execute a command in a new process.

  3. What is the difference between using a string and a list in Subprocess.Call?
  4. When using a string, the command and its arguments are passed as a single string. When using a list, each argument is passed as a separate element in the list.

  5. Which method is considered best practice?
  6. Using a list is generally considered best practice because it allows for better handling of arguments with spaces or special characters. It also makes it easier to dynamically build the command and its arguments using variables and string formatting.

  7. Are there any downsides to using a list instead of a string?
  8. One downside to using a list is that it requires more code to build the command and its arguments. Additionally, if the list contains user input, care must be taken to prevent injection attacks.

  9. Can you provide an example of using Subprocess.Call with a list?
  10. Sure! Here’s an example:

    • command = [ls, -l, /path/to/directory]

    This would execute the ls command with the -l flag, passing in /path/to/directory as an argument.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *