Is there a way to check if NumPy arrays share the same data?

Posted on

Question :

Is there a way to check if NumPy arrays share the same data?

My impression is that in NumPy, two arrays can share the same memory. Take the following example:

import numpy as np
print (b[0,0,0]) #5000

#Some tests: is #False == #True

c[0]=5000 == #True ( Same data, not same memory storage ), False positive

So clearly b didn’t make a copy of a; it just created some new meta-data and attached it to the same memory buffer that a is using. Is there a way to check if two arrays reference the same memory buffer?

My first impression was to use is, but that returns false. I can do == which returns True, but I don’t think that checks to make sure a and b share the same memory buffer, only that the block of memory referenced by a and the one referenced by b have the same bytes.

Asked By: mgilson


Answer #1:

I think jterrace’s answer is probably the best way to go, but here is another possibility.

def byte_offset(a):
    """Returns a 1-d array of the byte offset of every element in `a`.
    Note that these will not in general be in order."""
    stride_offset = np.ix_(*map(range,a.shape))
    element_offset = sum(i*s for i, s in zip(stride_offset,a.strides))
    element_offset = np.asarray(element_offset).ravel()
    return np.concatenate([element_offset + x for x in range(a.itemsize)])

def share_memory(a, b):
    """Returns the number of shared bytes between arrays `a` and `b`."""
    a_low, a_high = np.byte_bounds(a)
    b_low, b_high = np.byte_bounds(b)

    beg, end = max(a_low,b_low), min(a_high,b_high)

    if end - beg > 0:
        # memory overlaps
        amem = a_low + byte_offset(a)
        bmem = b_low + byte_offset(b)

        return np.intersect1d(amem,bmem).size
        return 0


>>> a = np.arange(10)
>>> b = a.reshape((5,2))
>>> c = a[::2]
>>> d = a[1::2]
>>> e = a[0:1]
>>> f = a[0:1]
>>> f = f.reshape(())
>>> share_memory(a,b)
>>> share_memory(a,c)
>>> share_memory(a,d)
>>> share_memory(c,d)
>>> share_memory(a,e)
>>> share_memory(a,f)

Here is a plot showing the time for each share_memory(a,a[::2]) call as a function of the number of elements in a on my computer.

share_memory function

Answered By: user545424

Answer #2:

You can use the base attribute to check if an array shares the memory with another array:

>>> import numpy as np
>>> a = np.arange(27)
>>> b = a.reshape((3,3,3))
>>> b.base is a
>>> a.base is b

Not sure if that solves your problem. The base attribute will be None if the array owns its own memory. Note that an array’s base will be another array, even if it is a subset:

>>> c = a[2:]
>>> c.base is a
Answered By: jterrace

Answer #3:

Just do:

a = np.arange(27)

The second line will return a tuple where the first entry is the memory address and the second is whether the array is read only. Combined with the shape and data type, you can figure out the exact span of memory address that the array covers, so you can also work out from this when one array is a subset of another.

Answered By: Nir Friedman

Answer #4:

To solve the problem exactly, you can use

import numpy as np


# Checks exactly by default
np.shares_memory(a, b)

# Checks bounds only
np.may_share_memory(a, b)

Both np.may_share_memory and np.shares_memory take an optional max_work argument that lets you decide how much effort to put in to ensure no false positives. This problem is NP-complete, so always finding the correct answer can be quite computationally expensive.

Answered By: b-butler

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *